Call UsBook Now


Must-Try Seafood Restaurants in Key West, FL

One of the best things about traveling is enjoying all the vibrant cuisines prepared and served at the local restaurants. You really get a chance to connect with the community you’re visiting and mingle with locals. Food can tell a lot about a place, from its history to its diversity. It is a great way of connecting with a variety of people and stories. You’ll make unforgettable memories and maybe even find your next favorite restaurant! Thankfully for you, Key West is home to several noteworthy restaurants, serving up cuisines from all over the world. The city’s seafood restaurants draw folks from all over, year after year. 


When you visit Key West this year, 1800 Atlantic is your go-to vacation rental destination. You’ll be provided with the best resort-style service and gorgeous vacation rentals, many of which sit on the stunning Florida beachfront. Our team is committed to helping you plan the best vacation to the Florida Keys and Key West! Keep reading to learn more about the must-try seafood restaurants in Key West, FL—

3 Top Seafood Restaurants in Key West

Do you feel like Eaton something? Well, you are in the right place when you visit this seafood restaurant! They are known for their crab cake and shrimp salad sandwiches. All seafood is caught by local fishermen and tastes incredibly fresh—it’s a must-try.

This is a casual seafood restaurant offering a limited yet delicious menu. People rave about their seafood rolls, paired with a choice of beer or wine. You can also enjoy a nice sweet treat of Kermit’s Key Lime Pie after a long meal. 

The restaurant’s motto is “where Northern & Southern seafood meet.” They were featured in an episode of Food Network’s Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives. Grab an Overstuffed Maine Lobster Roll or some Conch Fritters. You can check out their menu online. 

Now that you know all the best Key West seafood restaurants, you can get ready to plan your stay. 1800 Atlantic is excited to host you, whether you choose to reside in one of our Old Town properties or beachfront suites. There is a vacation rental for everyone. Book your stay online with us today! 

Book now for May/June & July promotions 4 night stays starting at $459 a night plus tax & feesClick for details
+ +